altmarius

cultură şi spiritualitate

The Sophistication of The Consolation

Detail of a miniature of the Wheel of Fortune, at the beginning of book 2 of the De Consolatione Philosophiae.

The Wheel of Fortune, at the beginning of Bbook 2 of the The Consolation of Philosophy by Boethius.

By Danièle Cybulskie

A couple of weeks ago, I talked (ranted) a little bit about the misconception that privacy, as a concept, was a relatively new idea. As I said then, it seems that people often seem to have this idea that our ancestors were not as smart as we are, although I have never found that to be the case. Culturally, medieval people were different than we are now, that’s undoubtedly true, but that doesn’t mean that they weren’t plagued by the same existential questions we are.

A case in point, and one of the most wonderful texts to influence and shape the Middle Ages, is The Consolation of Philosophy by Boethius. Written at the very beginning of what most historians consider the Middle Ages (523 C.E.), The Consolation is the work of a Roman politician, who wrote it while jailed and awaiting execution. Fortunately for us, Boethius takes some time to outline his downfall: some untrustworthy men proclaimed that he was interfering with the testimony of a witness who intended to accuse the Roman Senate of corruption. Boethius insists on his own integrity; in fact, it is because he so genuinely believes in the morality of his deeds that he is tormented by the unfairness of it all, turning to Philosophy for answers as to why good men sometimes fall to evil men. Through prose and poetry, Boethius and his imagined figure of Philosophy discuss how this happens, and what it means in the overall cosmic scheme of things.

Boethius’ questions and Philosophy’s answers are framed in a religious light – everything is explained through God’s divinity – but modern readers, religious or not, will find that The Consolation of Philosophy deals with the very questions humanity struggles with today: why are people evil? Why do bad things happen? Is it worth being moral when it doesn’t always pay off? Through carefully-structured logic, Philosophy leads Boethius from despair over what he’s lost, to hope and acceptance.

Here are some of Philosophy’s words of wisdom (these quotes are taken from Richard Green’s translation, which you can find here):

  • “If riches cannot eliminate need, but on the contrary create new demands, what makes you suppose they can provide satisfaction?” (Book III, Prose 3, p.48)
  • “What scoundrel is more deadly than one who has been a friend?” (Book III, Prose 5, p.52)
  • “In spite of the variety and difference of opinion, still all men agree in loving and pursuing the goal of good.” (Book III, Prose 2, p.45)

As you can see, Philosophy covers quite a lot of ground, from Fortune’s capriciousness to the nature of free will in the divine plan, making this a very thorough and sophisticated examination of major theological questions. By the end, Philosophy reassures Boethius that he has lost nothing of value by losing his place in politics or his fortune. Instead, he must only concentrate on what he can do to live morally, and the rest will take care of itself.

For hundreds of years, The Consolation of Philosophy was painstakingly copied, and copied again by hand to bring reassurance to medieval readers (and listeners) who questioned their own fates and fortunes. Clearly, people found Boethius’ words to be both relevant and resonant to them, and modern readers might easily find them to be so, as well. “Let us rise, if we can, to the summit of the highest intelligence,” (Book V, Prose 5, p.114) Philosophy said to Boethius centuries ago; let us recognize that intelligence in our ancestors as we work towards finding our own modern consolations.

You can follow Danièle Cybulskie on Twitter @5MinMedievalist

Click here to read more articles from the Five-Minute Medievalist

Vizualizări: 13

Adaugă un comentariu

Pentru a putea adăuga comentarii trebuie să fii membru al altmarius !

Alătură-te reţelei altmarius

Statistici

Free counters!
Din 15 iunie 2009

188 state (ultimul: Saint-Lucia)

Numar de steaguri: 251

Record vizitatori:    8,782 (3.04.2011)

Record clickuri:

 16,676 (3.04.2011)

Tari lipsa: 54

1 stat are peste 550,000 clickuri (Romania)

1 stat are peste 75.000 clickuri (USA)

1 stat are peste 40,000 clickuri (Moldova)

3 state au peste 10.000 clickuri (ItaliaFranta,  

Germania)

6 state au peste 5.000 clickuri (Olanda, Belgia, Marea Britanie, Canada, UngariaSpania )

9 state au peste 1,000 clickuri (Polonia, Rusia, Austria, IrlandaIsraelGreciaElvetia , Brazilia, Suedia)

35 state au peste 100 clickuri

25 state au un click

Rating for altmarius.ning.com 

altmarius.ning.com-Google pagerank,alexa rank,Competitor

DE URMĂRIT

1. ANTICARIAT ALBERT

http://anticariatalbert.com/

2. ANTICARIAT ODIN 

http://anticariat-odin.ro/

3. TARGUL CARTII

http://www.targulcartii.ro/

4. COLTUL COLECTIONARULUI

http://www.coltulcolectionarului.ro/

5. MAGAZINUL DE CARTE

http://www.magazinul-de-carte.ro/

6 ANTICARIAT PLUS

http://www.anticariatplus.ro/

7. PRINTRE CARTI

http://www.printrecarti.ro/

8. CARTEA DE CITIT

http://www.carteadecitit.ro/

9. ANTICARIAT ON-LINE
http://www.carti-online.com/

10. ANTICARIATUL DE NOAPTE

 http://www.anticariatuldenoapte.ro/

11. ANTICARIATUL NOU

http://www.anticariatulnou.ro

12. ANTICARIAT NOU

https://anticariatnou.wordpress.com/

13. DEPOZITUL DE CARTI 

http://www.calinblaga.ro/

14. ANTIKVARIUM.RO

http://antikvarium.ro

15. GALERIILE CISMIGIU

http://www.galeriile-cismigiu.ro/

16. ANTICARIAT LOGOS

http://www.anticariat-logos.ro/

17. ANTICARIAT.NET

http://www.anticariat.net/informatii-contact.php

18. TIMBREE

www.timbree.ro

19. FILATELIE

 http://www.romaniastamps.com/

20 MAX

http://romanianstampnews.blogspot.com

21. STAMPWORLD

http://www.stampworld.com

22. LIBMAG

https://www.libmag.ro/oferta-carti-polirom/?utm_source=facebook-ads-7-99-polirom&utm_medium=banner-facebook&utm_campaign=7-99-polirom-facebook&utm_content=new-3

23. BUCURESTIUL MEU DRAG

http://www.orasul.ro/

24. MAGIA MUNTELUI

http://magiamuntelui.blogspot.com

25. RAZVAN CODRESCU
http://razvan-codrescu.blogspot.ro/

26. POVESTI SASESTI

http://povestisasesti.com/

27. GHID VIDEO TURISTIC

http://www.ghidvideoturistic.ro/ghid-turistic/default.as

28 ORIZONTURI CULTURALE

http://www.orizonturiculturale.ro/ro_home.html

29. FILME DOCUMENTARE

http://www.filmedocumentare.com/filme-a-z/

30. SA NU UITAM

http://sanuuitam.blogspot.ro/

31. ISTORIA ROMANIEI

http://istoriaromaniei.com/wp/

32. MIRON MANEGA
http://www.certitudinea.o

33. NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC ROMANIA

https://www.natgeo.ro/revista

36. KORUNK

http://ideakonyvter.ro/53-korunk

Insignă

Se încarcă...

Anunturi

Licenţa Creative Commons Această retea este pusă la dispoziţie sub Licenţa Atribuire-Necomercial-FărăModificări 3.0 România Creativ

Note

Erfolgsgeschichte Taunusbahn

Creat de altmariusclassic Sep 13, 2013 at 11:02am. Actualizat ultima dată de altmariusclassic Sep 13, 2013.

© 2018   Created by altmarius.   Oferit de

Embleme  |  Raportare eroare  |  Termeni de utilizare a serviciilor