altmarius

cultură şi spiritualitate

Boethius’s Misguided Theodicy: The Consolation of Philosophy

Boethius’s Misguided Theodicy: The Consolation of Philosophy

By Justin McManus

Discoveries, Vol.4 (2002)

Boethius

Introduction: Anicius Boethius’s The Consolation of Philosophy (c. 524) is a bold attempt to reconcile the gravity of the author’s imprisonment and impending death with a world governed by a just God. In arguing his classic theodicy, Boethius reiterates the Augustinian belief that evil is really nonexistent. By challenging any capacity that the wicked have for real action, Boethius sidesteps the problem of evil in a just world by disputing its actual influence. Yet the pain and suffering that so poignantly characterize the human condition must refute Boethius’s counterintuitive assertion. His abstraction, in fact, describes an ultimately absurd universe because he assembles it with a faulty style of argumentation. Boethius’s overreliance upon the equation of dissimilar concepts, for instance, results in a text that is laden with contradictions and often plagued by oversimplifications. More important, though, is his fundamentally flawed understanding of evil. Instead of seriously considering the possible benefits of injustice acknowledged by suffering, Boethius errs in assuming that the existence of evil is necessarily inconsistent with an all-loving, just God. Boethius’s dubious mode of argumentation and his fundamental misunderstanding of evil doom the theodicy of The Consolation to failure.

The most readily apparent flaw in Boethius’s theodicy is his tendency to equate dissimilar ideas. His reliance on equivalency surfaces most disturbingly when his imagined guardian, Philosophy, claims that real happiness is a uniform, undivided amalgam of self-sufficiency, power, fame, and glory. To prove her assertion, Philosophy awkwardly equates all of these components with happiness itself. First, she holds that because self-sufficiency is a state replete with power, the two ideals of self-sufficiency and power are really one and the same. Going further, she prompts Boethius to admit that one would revere rather than despise a self-sufficient being, so that self-sufficiency, power, and respect must all describe the same ideal. Using the same mode of argumentation, Philosophy continues to equate fame and finally true happiness with the other previously equated values. Yet there are two immediately obvious faults with this type of reasoning.

Click here to read this article from Cornell University

Vizualizări: 11

Adaugă un comentariu

Pentru a putea adăuga comentarii trebuie să fii membru al altmarius !

Alătură-te reţelei altmarius

Statistici

Free counters!
Din 15 iunie 2009

188 state (ultimul: Saint-Lucia)

Numar de steaguri: 251

Record vizitatori:    8,782 (3.04.2011)

Record clickuri:

 16,676 (3.04.2011)

Tari lipsa: 54

1 stat are peste 550,000 clickuri (Romania)

1 stat are peste 75.000 clickuri (USA)

1 stat are peste 40,000 clickuri (Moldova)

3 state au peste 10.000 clickuri (ItaliaFranta,  

Germania)

6 state au peste 5.000 clickuri (Olanda, Belgia, Marea Britanie, Canada, UngariaSpania )

9 state au peste 1,000 clickuri (Polonia, Rusia, Austria, IrlandaIsraelGreciaElvetia , Brazilia, Suedia)

35 state au peste 100 clickuri

25 state au un click

Rating for altmarius.ning.com 

altmarius.ning.com-Google pagerank,alexa rank,Competitor

DE URMĂRIT

1. ANTICARIAT ALBERT

http://anticariatalbert.com/

2. ANTICARIAT ODIN 

http://anticariat-odin.ro/

3. TARGUL CARTII

http://www.targulcartii.ro/

4. COLTUL COLECTIONARULUI

http://www.coltulcolectionarului.ro/

5. MAGAZINUL DE CARTE

http://www.magazinul-de-carte.ro/

6 ANTICARIAT PLUS

http://www.anticariatplus.ro/

7. PRINTRE CARTI

http://www.printrecarti.ro/

8. CARTEA DE CITIT

http://www.carteadecitit.ro/

9. ANTICARIAT ON-LINE
http://www.carti-online.com/

10. ANTICARIATUL DE NOAPTE

 http://www.anticariatuldenoapte.ro/

11. ANTICARIATUL NOU

http://www.anticariatulnou.ro

12. ANTICARIAT NOU

https://anticariatnou.wordpress.com/

13. DEPOZITUL DE CARTI 

http://www.calinblaga.ro/

14. ANTIKVARIUM.RO

http://antikvarium.ro

15. GALERIILE CISMIGIU

http://www.galeriile-cismigiu.ro/

16. ANTICARIAT LOGOS

http://www.anticariat-logos.ro/

17. ANTICARIAT.NET

http://www.anticariat.net/informatii-contact.php

18. TIMBREE

www.timbree.ro

19. FILATELIE

 http://www.romaniastamps.com/

20 MAX

http://romanianstampnews.blogspot.com

21. STAMPWORLD

http://www.stampworld.com

22. LIBMAG

https://www.libmag.ro/oferta-carti-polirom/?utm_source=facebook-ads-7-99-polirom&utm_medium=banner-facebook&utm_campaign=7-99-polirom-facebook&utm_content=new-3

23. BUCURESTIUL MEU DRAG

http://www.orasul.ro/

24. MAGIA MUNTELUI

http://magiamuntelui.blogspot.com

25. RAZVAN CODRESCU
http://razvan-codrescu.blogspot.ro/

26. POVESTI SASESTI

http://povestisasesti.com/

27. GHID VIDEO TURISTIC

http://www.ghidvideoturistic.ro/ghid-turistic/default.as

28 ORIZONTURI CULTURALE

http://www.orizonturiculturale.ro/ro_home.html

29. FILME DOCUMENTARE

http://www.filmedocumentare.com/filme-a-z/

30. SA NU UITAM

http://sanuuitam.blogspot.ro/

31. ISTORIA ROMANIEI

http://istoriaromaniei.com/wp/

32. MIRON MANEGA
http://www.certitudinea.o

33. NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC ROMANIA

https://www.natgeo.ro/revista

36. KORUNK

http://ideakonyvter.ro/53-korunk

Insignă

Se încarcă...

Anunturi

Licenţa Creative Commons Această retea este pusă la dispoziţie sub Licenţa Atribuire-Necomercial-FărăModificări 3.0 România Creativ

Note

Erfolgsgeschichte Taunusbahn

Creat de altmariusclassic Sep 13, 2013 at 11:02am. Actualizat ultima dată de altmariusclassic Sep 13, 2013.

© 2018   Created by altmarius.   Oferit de

Embleme  |  Raportare eroare  |  Termeni de utilizare a serviciilor